SHERLOCK HOLMES: THE VATICAN CAMEOS
Ellicott Creek Software, 1986
=============================
Hints by Exemptus - March 2026
Overview and general hints:
---------------------------
As Sherlock Holmes, we have received word from our brother Mycroft that the
famous Vatican Cameos have been stolen while en route to London and the agent
that he had aboard the ship that carried them has gone missing. At the same
time, we are confronted with Pelton, a man who is accused of murdering another
one of the boarding house tenants he lived with, and pleads Sherlock to defend
his case, claiming his innocence. As it turns out, both cases dovetail into each
other, but we will only have four days to unravel the mystery.
This game is unusual in several aspects. First, it does not have a proper
parser: actions are chosen from a menu instead. We can MOVE to a place, LOOK at
things, EXAMINE them, ASK people about things, READ objects, and issue other
few miscellaneous commands. There is also a way to use arbitrary verb-object
commands, but only the verbs PUSH, OPEN, SHUT and TURN are recognized.
Second, the geography is a set of discrete single-room locations that we have to
move between by using MOVE, but we need to know the name of the location first,
plus an area (the "central construct") which we can explore using the
traditional N/E/S/W/U/D commands. This area can only be visited once: if we
leave it, we can no longer return, so it needs to be thoroughly explored first.
Third, there is no inventory, as we can carry no objects. Some things are
implicitly accessed anywhere, like a telegram that arrives at a certain point,
and it's assumed we carry it with us.
The game is also timed. There are two timers: one that counts real time and
clocks one hour of game time every few minutes. The other keeps track of game
time. The game begins at 10:00 AM on April 21, 1888 and ends at 11:00 PM on
April 24, 1888 (or before, depending on how the game goes). Some events happen
at fixed times, day and night influence what places we can visit or not, and
we also need to SLEEP and EAT at regular intervals (although this is not
strictly needed). Holmes and Watson need to be in the right place at the right
time for some things to happen.
The game flow is purely investigative: clues are gathered by examining things
and asking people about things. There is a good deal of information we have at
the start, which is provided by the manual and casebook, and NPCs will name
other places, people and things to explore. With some restrictions, we have
plenty of freedom to go where we please.
Regrettably, surviving copies of the game seem to be buggy, or maybe this was
also true of the original. The game seems to be rather unstable and some
things that depend on time are difficult to reproduce. Supposedly, the endgame
triggers on its own at a certain point in time, provided we have advanced enough
in our enquiries, but I have only managed to finish the game once: all other
playthroughs either didn't trigger certain events, or actions that were possible
before suddenly weren't, or it was impossible to access key clues because the
game did not change internal states as supposed to. This is the main reason I'm
not providing a reproducible solution.
The manual and casebook are of the essence: without them the player simply does
not know enough to go on. Difficulty is compounded by the fact that objects
behave inconsistently regarding LOOK and EXAMINE: the manual states that LOOK
is for things that cannot be handled and EXAMINE for the ones that can, but this
is not always true. If one does not work with an object, try another.
The investigation is enjoyable, well constructed (save for the timed events not
working sometimes) and faithful to the Conan Doyle style and canon, as is the
writing, so I'm providing a number of hints that will allow the player to move
the investigation forward. The map lists all possible 60 locations, and any can
be reached at any moment except if limited by timings, because the game does not
track what Sherlock knows or finds out. Of course, one should not try to visit a
location unless it has been previously mentioned, but it will work anyway, which
can make for some messy playthroughs.
The game was the object of a competition back in 1986, which I'm not aware
anybody won, so it being difficult to complete should not be a surprise, but it
is unforgiving: the player must deduce everything from the given clues. Some
characters lie, there are a number of red herrings, and some inferences are more
assumptions that deductions, but the whole affair can be untangled, provided we
are thorough in our exploration of items and conversations.
I'm giving below a list of all conversation subjects that can be raised with
every character at every location. This will be nonsensical unless the player
has previously heard about some of the conversation topics, of course, but some
of them can be raised even if not (e.g., you can ASK LESTRADE ABOUT LETTER
before even knowing of its existence), so it's somewhat spoilery.
Some place names are not immediate to find out. There are three ships we can
visit at any time: the SS Mary Hamilton, the SS Pretoria, and the SS Crimea, but
only the two former are location names. In order to visit the Crimea, you need
to name individual rooms on it (such the stateroom or the purser's office).
With Argyle house the same happens, which is baffling: instead of navigating the
house, we have to MOVE to the BEDROOM, the KITCHEN or the STUDY for some reason.
It doesn't help that this is a key location.
I won't be giving away the story, as it is enjoyable to find out, but for the
impatient I'll give an account of what are the final answers that allow to
finish the endgame. Don't go any further unless you want spoilers.
***SPOILERS BEGIN HERE***
List of Conversation Topics by Location:
----------------------------------------
Butler's:
ASK LESTRADE ABOUT:
TRELLIS
LOCKS
BOARDERS
SERVANT
WEAPON
LAKLY
ASK SERVANT ABOUT:
KNIVES
ASK LAKLY ABOUT:
PIEDMONT
PELTON
Scotland Yard:
ASK LESTRADE ABOUT:
PELTON
GUN
KNIFE
ACID
LETTER
Jail:
ASK PELTON ABOUT:
KNIFE
ACID
BOYLE
PIEDMONT
LETTER
CARR
Conroy (only accessible later in the game):
ASK CONROY ABOUT:
PELTON
Carey's Tobacco Shop:
ASK CAREY ABOUT:
TOBACCO
CUSTOMERS
Liddle & Grey:
ASK BRYANT ABOUT:
TOBACCO
CAREY
CAMEOS
Depaul & Resizes:
ASK DEPAUL ABOUT:
COLLECTION
CAMEOS
SHAW
Docks:
ASK PORTER ABOUT:
BANDANA
ANGEL
WARNEK
Bilestone Road:
ASK LANDLADY ABOUT:
WARNEK
Bender's Pawnshop:
ASK BENDER ABOUT:
PAWNTICKET
WARNEK
Shipping Office:
ASK GOLDING ABOUT:
PASSENGERS
SS Pretoria:
ASK MASTER ABOUT:
PASSENGERS
SS Mary Hamilton:
ASK PURSER ABOUT:
PASSENGERS
SHAW
The Angel:
ASK BARKEEP ABOUT:
MORAN
WARNEK
KENRAW
Buxton's Hotel:
ASK CLERK ABOUT:
SHAW
Leicester Suite:
ASK SHAW ABOUT:
CAMEOS
NONPAREIL
MORAN
COLLECTION
Ryder Agency:
ASK MARTIN ABOUT:
WARNEK
Mayback's Chemists:
ASK CLERK ABOUT:
DUMFREY
JACOBS
CARR
VITRIOL
REGISTER
Joshua Reynolds & Co:
ASK REYNOLDS ABOUT:
PELTON
Drucker's:
ASK EASTON ABOUT:
WARNEK
Purser's office:
ASK ABRAMS ABOUT:
PASSENGERS
Diogenes Club (only accessible later in the game):
ASK MYCROFT ABOUT:
CAMEOS
SHIP
THEFT
AGENT
TELEGRAM
CARDINAL
SHAW (after telegram arrives)
MORAN (after telegram arrives)
TELEGRAM (after telegram arrives)
National Museum:
ASK DISANTORO ABOUT:
CAMEOS
VALUE
TRIP
THEFT
STATEROOM
Non-Pareil Club:
ASK CONCIERGE ABOUT:
MORAN
SHAW
List of Answers in the Endgame:
-------------------------------
Q: Who, in your opinion, is the murderer of one Joshua Piedmont?
A: Not dead
Q: Who do you believe planned the theft of the Vatican Cameos?
A: Moriarty
Q: Where did this crime take place?
A: SS Crimea
Q: When did this crime take place? Please answer with the full month-name and day.
A: April 9
Q: Who actually committed the theft?
A: Kenraw
Q: Where is this person now?
A: Dead
Q: On whose instigation was this theft planned and executed?
A: Shaw
Q: Where is Hugh Carr?
A: Home
Q: Where were the Cameos held secreted?
A: Anchor
Q: Name one person, not yet mentioned, who was a co-conspirator in this crime.
A: Moran